PublicLooking at
a summary of the deal, it seems fairly thin gruel. Better than nothing, much better in a few areas, but not quite the triumph Keir Starmer's comms team were trying to paint it as in the immediate aftermath of the announcement. The sanitary and phytosanitary agreement for food is a definite plus, and dynamic alignment is a reasonable price to pay. Fishing is a thornier question: a
twelve-year extension to the current deal is a huge win for France in particular. Absolutely nobody I read in the run-up to this deal predicted more than ten years max, and most four. On the other hand, though politically totemic fishing is a very minor industry in overall UK terms -- and the Scottish salmon industry, the biggest single fish exporter to the EU, supports the deal.
A youth mobility scheme is clearly a good thing, and since we already have similar agreements with Australia, Canada and several other countries it
shouldn't be controversial. Labour's obsession with "red lines" means that anything even fringing on freedom of movement, the single market etc wasn't up for discussion. Public opinion has moved on this, but Starmer is
very stubborn about it. Then there's the question of e-gates at EU airports. This is a good example of the government's poor comms outfit: they let it be reported initially that the UK had agreed a Swiss-style deal that would allow British holidaymakers to use
all EU airports' e-gates. Because of that, finding out it will still be up to individual member states felt like a real let-down.
The UK government and the EU have
still not done much more than agreed to further talks on the issue of red tape and costs for British musicians touring Europe. I think that this failure reflects badly on both sides, as after
years of artists pushing for this, it really shouldn't be difficult to agree a limited regime for this specific group. It's taken far too long already. Not a lot has happened on mutual UK-EU recognition of professional qualifications, either, which is again disappointing. There's a suspicion that the EU doesn't really want to try too hard on this one since an agreement would open up a big extra chunk of European business to British firms.
All in all? The agreement on food is great and will substantially reduce the red tape that's existed since Brexit. It should also make sending food between Great Britain and Northern Ireland easier. The rest of the agreement seems to be mostly mood music rather than concrete action. Mood music isn't
worthless, as at least it shows that a closer partnership with the EU is something the UK government is willing to shout about again. Hopefully the days of "what we need is
real Brexit" will now fade into history, depending on what Nigel Farage does. These UK-EU summits will take place annually, so maybe, just maybe, we might get a little more progress in 2026.